Post a Reply
Back to the Forum
WTF? This is getting a tad ridiculous. Seriously.
Posted: 12:32 Jun 01 2005
Brett Ratner directing X-Men 3
That's right folks, Matthew Vaughn has left the production of X-Men 3 for personal reasons, so the film, which is supposed to be shooting in 9 weeks, has no director.
Rumour is, they want someone who circled the film earlier, but was unavailable to take over, but who that is is unknown. I vote for Joss, but i dunno if he's finished Serenity.
EDIT:
That's right, Brett Ratner, who was attached to Superman for ages, is now taking over the train wreck that is X-Men 3. *yawn*
Not an appointment that really excites me about the possibilities.
(Edited by Maffrew 06/06/2005 14:10)
Rumour is, they want someone who circled the film earlier, but was unavailable to take over, but who that is is unknown. I vote for Joss, but i dunno if he's finished Serenity.
EDIT:
That's right, Brett Ratner, who was attached to Superman for ages, is now taking over the train wreck that is X-Men 3. *yawn*
Not an appointment that really excites me about the possibilities.
(Edited by Maffrew 06/06/2005 14:10)
10 Replies and 3762 Views in Total.
Posted: 12:32 Jun 01 2005 
And I heard recently that the casting decisions made during Vaughn's time in the big chair may now be thrown out of the window, which may mean no Vinnie Jones as Juggie, or worse - no Kelsey Grammar as Beast!
Nooooo!!
Nooooo!!
Posted: 12:49 Jun 06 2005
Well, the Rush Hour films were cool, and Red Dragon wasn't too bad either, I suppose.
Hmmm... Superman Lives (as it was called at the time) - a film with no clear director, no confirmed lead, no clear script, or clear anything, until the nearly set-in-stone X3's director jumps ship.
And now Supes is progressing nicely, whilst X3 looks set to flounder in the Savage Land that is Development Hell (Sorry, couldn't resist!
*awaits well-earned slap for being a sad little nerd* 
) - there's going to be at least one more big problem, mark my words!
EDIT: Hopefully, they'll keep the casting changes made while Vaughn was involved, because I think Kelsey Grammar as Beast is just inspired...
(Edited by Alan 07/06/2005 10:07)
Hmmm... Superman Lives (as it was called at the time) - a film with no clear director, no confirmed lead, no clear script, or clear anything, until the nearly set-in-stone X3's director jumps ship.
And now Supes is progressing nicely, whilst X3 looks set to flounder in the Savage Land that is Development Hell (Sorry, couldn't resist!
*awaits well-earned slap for being a sad little nerd* ) - there's going to be at least one more big problem, mark my words!EDIT: Hopefully, they'll keep the casting changes made while Vaughn was involved, because I think Kelsey Grammar as Beast is just inspired...
(Edited by Alan 07/06/2005 10:07)
Posted: 09:54 Jun 07 2005
Hmm... everyone seems to forget that Beast is, in fact, about thirty...
Not that it really matters, and I expect Beast may be mostly computer generated anyway. Kelsey Grammer is a bit of an obvious choice, but probably a good one.
Vinnie Jones I'm not too sure about, but makes a sort of sense given Xavier is english in the films. Although I'd rather just not have Juggernaut in it at all.
But, as had been said, these casting decisions may be out of the window anyway.
Not that it really matters, and I expect Beast may be mostly computer generated anyway. Kelsey Grammer is a bit of an obvious choice, but probably a good one.
Vinnie Jones I'm not too sure about, but makes a sort of sense given Xavier is english in the films. Although I'd rather just not have Juggernaut in it at all.
But, as had been said, these casting decisions may be out of the window anyway.
Posted: 10:37 Jun 08 2005
Well, failing Kelsey Grammar, there's always David Hyde Pierce... *checks IMDb* - holy crap! He's 46; a few months older than my Dad! 
Posted: 14:19 Jun 08 2005 
Or that Wolverine is only 5'3" tall!!!
by Demona
Hmm... everyone seems to forget that Beast is, in fact, about thirty...
Or that Jean Grey is actually supposed to be incredibly attractive!!!
Or that Cyc is supposed be a tw... oh wait a minute
I think we have to go for a lot or artistic licence in all the characters, Kelsey has the right voice for the character given the cartoon shows and such, so I can't actually think of anyone better! But yes, definately the obvious choice, but sometimes obvious is obvious for the right reasons
by Demona
Not that it really matters, and I expect Beast may be mostly computer generated anyway. Kelsey Grammer is a bit of an obvious choice, but probably a good one.
Posted: 19:28 Jun 08 2005 Yeah, but everyone commented on the fact that Hugh Jackman was too tall for Wolverine. No-one I've spoken too seemed to notice that Kelsey Grammar was too old for the comic-book Beast. But as I said, it doesn't matter; I'd rather they did something that worked in the context of a film than slavishly followed 40 years of inconsistent continuity.
by MonSTeR
(quotes)
Or that Wolverine is only 5'3" tall!!!
Famke Janssen does it for me.
Or that Jean Grey is actually supposed to be incredibly attractive!!!
Posted: 15:22 Jun 09 2005
Yeah well, all niggly little points considered (Wolvie being short, Pyro being Australian, etc.), I think it's all worked out pretty well; IMHO, Hugh Jackman makes a pretty good Ol' Canucklehead, as well as Famke Janssen being a pretty nice choice for Jean Grey - but neither of them a patch on Ian McKellen's Magneto ("You homo sapiens and your guns!''). All in all, I thought the casting was pretty much spot on.
Posted: 13:22 Jun 10 2005
BAMF! Alan Cumming teleports out of X3
Goddamit! One of the best characters and actors in the second movie by far and Fox give him the boot - what the hell were they thinking? Were they thinking at all?
Now I shall go and vent my frustrations somewhere where my language won't trigger a wave of Sentinels...
Goddamit! One of the best characters and actors in the second movie by far and Fox give him the boot - what the hell were they thinking? Were they thinking at all?
Now I shall go and vent my frustrations somewhere where my language won't trigger a wave of Sentinels...
Posted: 23:11 Jun 23 2005