The most conservative estimates believed that a US invasion of Japan would cost 1 million lives, both American and Japanese. The Japanese government of the time was never going to be forced to surrender by conventional means; the brutal "island hopping" campaign in the Pacific gave a grim foretaste of what an invasion of mainland Japan would have been like.
We can't fairly judge people with the benefit of hindsight; we can only look at whether their actions were right in the context of the time. Faced as they were with an alternative that was even more horrendous than using the atomic bomb, and no other way out, I think the US was right to do what it did.
We can't fairly judge people with the benefit of hindsight; we can only look at whether their actions were right in the context of the time. Faced as they were with an alternative that was even more horrendous than using the atomic bomb, and no other way out, I think the US was right to do what it did.